I'm going to be very honest here.
The first one was the best. The recolors were crap.
Firstly, the recolors look like they have high contrast and a bit of flatness to them. I liked the first because you could see the shine.
Secondly, it looks like you spammed the image with brushes. I can barely read the words because the brushes overlaps in some parts.
I give it a 6/10, good try.