Toribash
I honestly didn't find Amnesia: TDD scary.

I thought Penumbra was alot more tense and frightening, if i'm honest.
the house is scarier than hotel626,hotel626 is not scary at all
so i say the house
I will be my undoing if i become my obsession
I quit.
Scariest i've played myself would be Doom 3. I'm pretty jumpy, i don't go out of my way to find scary games (in fact i go out of my way to AVOID them). Scariest game i've seen being played is Amnesia: TDD, hands down. Being somewhat afraid of the dark doesn't help one bit. Perfectly summed up here.
<Blam|Homework> oiubt veubg
various places to find me lol