Ranking
Original Post
[VID] Crimson Roses
I've obviously never been any good at editing, but for once the quality of the render is actually decent.
The edit itself still sucks, so I need some CnC.

That generally gives a good opinion, but if you look closer there still are some issues:

The intro is pretty nice, but the running replay after it is pretty slow compared to the song (In my opinion), and also at 0:25 when the replay gets a little lighter, the transition isn't right. The following transition is pretty nice. Everything goes pretty well until the video reaches the part with the flying body part hitting that head. The following camera is good, but when the part hits the head it doesn't look like it fits with the song, maybe because you didn't amplify the effects enough as the song 'demands'. Nothing wrong in particular after that, just that the camera angles still need some work and some more sync.
I would rate the editing as somewhat good, and I believe that it didn't end up too well because you chose a difficult song to work with. It's still good, but could improve.
Originally Posted by translate.google.com View Post
All is well, just a bit dark in places and work on slow-downs =)

yep.