Which version are you using?
Current Updated beta version has quite a few bugs regarding replay opening.
Try going into the default.cfg with notepad and changing all the settings(ray-tracing, shaders, reflections, e.t.c.) to 0, set the fps to 30 as well. Your computer may not be able to handle the ray-tracing requirements if it's on. It may register as being able to run it, but certain hardware(cpu) might be too weak. Ray-tracing requires a powerful computer to run at 60fps, much less even 30fps