Photoshop quick retouch... if I had to do it properly I would also have redraw coupple of hair, retouch a bit the colors and fix that cheekbone.

You transformed a crackwhore into a normal non-crackwhore women, good job, but i really think the hair is nice like this, doesnt even look that fake either

it is appearing fake,
maybe you should keep some wrinkles.

its the underside of the right eye that is the problem, it doesn't have that same skin under the eye that the left eye has, the outer side of the eye also has some shadow problems. Other than that I think you did an amazing job, it doesn't look fake and blurry like 90% of the non-professional retouching jobs I've seen.